Let's see...
Shadow Man

Shadow

Thunder Beam

[Ice Slasher]{ice_cutter}

Flash Man's stage

Well, alright, since I can't vote for Metal Man, even though he is my favorite...

Favorite Robot Master:
Shadow Man, Elec Man, and Sword Man

Favorite Core types:
Cutter, Freeze, and Electric

Favorite Classic series weapon:
Shadow Blade, Top Spin, and Jewel Satellite

Favorite Ability:
Thunder Beam, Shadow Blade, and Ice Slasher

Favorite Classic series stages:
Knight Man, Jewel Man, and Metal Man (if that last one isn't valid, then I'll go with Blade Man)

Edit: Ugh, how do I make dual core show up? >.<
Also, I'm kind of surprised that favorite classic series music isn't an option...

Second Edit: Thanks for that, MegabossMan. Also, my first choice would probably be Protoman's theme, though MM2 Wily 1 would be a close second... Shadow Man and Metal Man both have good music too though

Well, why not. I've only actually played 1-6 and some of 9 and Mega Man and Bass, but hey, here you go.
10. Toad Man (He's got a good design, and a pretty good weapon)
9. Gemini Man (He's blue, shiny, and has one of the coolest ability sets ever, with cloning and lasers)
8. Cut Man (First one I ever beat, and his Powered Up personality is amusing)
7. Knight Man (First of many of my blade-related favorites, I just like his design)
6. Sword Man (Haven't ever fought him, but he has a giant sword and a good design)
5. Blade Man (Also haven't fought him, but his arms are swords. And so is his face. Enough said)
4. Ice Man (He's amusing and has a rather clever Eskimo-esque design)
3. Elec Man (The hardest boss for me in MM1, and he has my favorite weapon out of the 6)
2. Shadow Man (He's a ninja. That is all that needs to be said)
1. Metal Man (Good design, hilariously powerful weapon, and a catchy stage theme, especially the Megas' version of it)

Not an issue Brorman and thanks Adrian. Chespin appears to be a popular choice. I got one too. I did get a Ditto, so if anyone needs a Chespin, I can provide. Also, if anyone is interested, I'll put my friend code up when I get back to it. And, to add to this comment's numerous edits, what Kanto starters did everyone choose? I myself got Squirtle so I could have grass, fire, and water starters thanks to the Torchic event going on. Alright, one more edit, where do I find my friend code? Is it just the normal 3DS one?

Well I suppose I should ask then, does anyone have a Fennekin? I'm working on getting a Ditto so I can have some Chespin to trade, but Fennekin's the only new starter I don't have.

Thanks for feedback, I've been kind of surprised at the lack of it. Honestly, I just want this to be a thing even if I'm not involved at all...

@vaati Those sound pretty good, especially if I reevaluate and put Kirby in, which I'm a bit surprised I didn't do. Might swap him for Fox, or add a bonus stage a la Mega Man Unlimited's Yoku Man.

Yeah, all of those ideas sound interesting, and Ran would be kind of fun, but Bob and George ended years ago, so finding permission would be hard. Jazz/some other name for a new robot would be cool. Can't wait to see the final result, as much as I would love to be able to go all Shadow Man on things.

Well, it's been a while since anyone posted here, but I may as well. I'm NinjaLink, as you may have guessed. I've been a gamer for most of my life, though I only really became interested in Mega Man after the Smash Bros. announcement in June. I enjoy drawing and reading in my spare time when I'm not either playing a game or doing the ridiculous amount of homework high school seems to require, and I also aspire to work on a gaming project some day. That's just about it, so thanks to Adrian for making such a great game!

Out of curiosity, (I've been playing Megaman and Bass some recently) is the Ice Wall going to work similarly to the Super Arm? So that the first usage of it makes the wall and the second throws it?

Let's see here...
1. Proto Man
2. Shadow Man
3. Metal Man
4. Gemini Man
5. Elec Man

I have some ideas for Shadow Man
Start: My name is Shadow Man, and I will be your end.
Taunt: You can't defeat a shadow!
Victory: You weren't worth the trouble.
Defeat: I'll give you this one.